Not hasty
Methods and sources
Where every number comes from, how it is made, and what this site cannot tell you.
The source
Everything here is read from the agendas, minutes and board packets that Smyth County publishes on smythcounty.gov. Nothing comes from interviews, tips or anyone's account of a meeting. This snapshot was made on November 18, 2026 from 401 documents (24,361 pages) covering 580 meetings since January 9, 2001.
The county's documents are the record. Where this site and a county document disagree, the document is right.
One page is the exception: How Smyth compares is read from the state Auditor of Public Accounts' yearly report, described below.
How each part is made
- Motions and roll calls
- Software reads the text of the minutes and picks out each motion, who moved and seconded it, the names listed for and against, and the outcome. Names are matched to supervisors across the different ways the minutes spell them. A spelling no supervisor's name has, such as “Peny” for Perry, is matched only when exactly one supervisor sitting that day has a name within two letters of it; the motion text keeps the minutes' spelling. The short label on each motion is made by fixed rules and, for recent meetings, tidied by a language model; the motion text shown under it is copied from the minutes.
- Draft minutes
- The county posts a meeting's minutes after the Board approves them, at a later meeting. Until then, the packet for the next meeting prints them as a draft. Where a meeting has no minutes on file, its motions are read from that draft and marked as draft on the meeting's page. They count in no supervisor's record and appear in no list of votes, because the Board can correct a draft before it approves it. It has: for the meeting of December 12, 2024, the draft lists one supervisor as voting against eight motions, and the approved minutes list him as voting for all eight. When the county posts the minutes, the draft is dropped and the meeting is read from the minutes. A date that has minutes printed in a packet and no meeting on file gets a meeting made from that draft: a special called meeting often has no agenda posted and is known only this way, and so is a regular meeting whose minutes the county did not post. A draft whose motions are already on file under another date is taken to be that meeting's minutes with the date mistyped, and makes no meeting. Checked in November 2026 against the 40 meetings since January 2025 that have both a draft and posted minutes: the motions and roll calls read from the draft were the same as the minutes' at 38 of them, and 542 of 543 motions matched.
- Supervisors' records
- Counted from those roll calls. A motion that passed without a roll call by name counts toward no one. A supervisor is counted at a meeting when any roll call or motion that day names them, and absent when the roll calls only list them as absent.
- Budget numbers
- Read from the budget worksheets printed in the board packets: fund, department, line, and the amount in each column (actual, adopted budget, revised budget). Totals printed on the worksheet are compared with the sum of their lines.
- Findings
- Fixed rules, listed below, applied to those budget numbers. No judgment is involved and no model writes them. The same rules run on the packets before the latest one, which is how a finding is marked new or changed.
- Where the Board took up a finding
- A search of the minutes and motions for the department's name, its lines and the same dollar amount. It is matching by words, so it can match a passage that is about something else and miss one that uses different words.
- Meeting summaries
- Written by a language model from the meeting's documents and marked as such wherever they appear. They are a guide to what to read, not a record. Where a meeting's minutes are not on file, the summary is made from the agenda and packet alone, and the page says so: it can say what was scheduled, not what happened. A packet also carries the minutes of the meeting before, for the Board to approve. The software leaves those pages out of what the model reads, by their opening line or page heading through to the adjournment, and tells the model not to report anything from an earlier meeting. If it misses some, the summary may describe that earlier meeting.
- Charts
- Each chart is drawn when the site is built, from the numbers printed in the table beside or below it, and the source links are in that table. Every chart starts at zero, so the height of a point or the length of a bar is in proportion to its number. A hollow point, a dotted line or a pale bar marks a number that is not a finished actual: a budget figure, or a year still in progress. Where charts sit side by side, or a chart is made of rows, each says whether its parts share a scale. The small lines in the table of departments draw years that are in the data files and not on the page. Nothing on this site runs a script, the charts included.
How Smyth compares: the state's report
Each year the Virginia Auditor of Public Accounts publishes the Comparative Report of Local Government Revenues and Expenditures, built from the reports every county and city files with the state. The comparison page shows fiscal year 2025, from the amended report of October 5, 2026. Its numbers were read from the Auditor's workbook by a program, not typed, and the reading is kept with the site's code: each number with its sheet and cell, and the workbook's SHA-256, so a later download can be told apart from the file that was read. The program refuses a workbook whose columns have moved or whose per-person figure is not its amount over the population. Before a snapshot is published, it is checked again: Smyth and each of the six bordering counties must be there with every number and its cell, or nothing is published.
The Auditor's numbers are not the county's budget worksheets. They are what each county reported for a closed year, sorted into the Auditor's categories. Counties sort the same service differently, share services with neighbors, and leave services to their towns, and a figure per person divides by everyone in the county, towns included. The page says so beside the numbers, and it does not rank counties. Where the workbook disagrees with itself, the page says that too.
The rules behind the findings
- Fund deficit
- A fund spent more than it took in for two closed years running, or by $250K or more in the latest one. A single year short only because money was moved out to another fund does not count.
- Out of pattern
- Spending in the latest closed year changed by $50K or more and by at least three times the department's usual yearly change (and at least 15%). Spending that moved to a department of the same name in another fund is counted in both.
- Over budget
- A closed year's spending passed its budget by 10% and $50K or more. Two years in a row rank higher. The budget is the latest amended one printed once the year had begun, or the adopted one; a year with neither in the packets is not judged. A budget printed by the year's end (or the adopted one) is used only when the minutes on file record no amendment of that year's budget voted on or after the day it was printed; otherwise, or for a year before FY2022, whose amendments are not read, the year is not judged.
- Amended mid-year
- This year's amendments move a department's budget by $50K or more and by at least 10% of what was adopted.
- Changed since the last packet
- This year's budget for a department differs by $50K or more from the previous packet that printed it.
- Planned change
- This year's budget is 25% and $100K or more away from last year's spending, and amendments do not explain it.
- New line
- A line of $250K or more this year that had no money in any earlier year the worksheet prints. Money carried forward from earlier years is not new.
- Under budget
- A closed year's spending in a General Fund department came in 25% and $100K or more below its budget, measured as for over budget.
- One-time money
- A fund's budget this year counts on $250K or more of borrowing, savings, asset sales or placeholders, and for at least 5% of the revenue the budget prints for the fund.
- Revenue short of budget
- A closed year's revenue from one source came in 10% and $100K or more below its budget, measured as for over budget and leaving out borrowing, savings, asset sales and placeholders. Two years in a row rank higher.
- Revenue plan
- This year's budget expects 15% and $100K or more above or below what a source brought in last year, and amendments do not explain it.
- Revenue out of pattern
- Revenue from one source in the latest closed year changed by $50K or more and by at least three times its usual yearly change (and at least 15%).
Comparisons not made
A closed year is compared with its budget only when the minutes on file record no amendment of that year's budget voted on or after the day the budget was printed. A budget printed after the year ended is usually the appropriation in one of the county's accounting reports in a Board packet; the report does not say whether the year's books were closed, and pages of it that are scanned images are not read. 29 closed years were left out for this reason, though the budget as printed would have made them findings:
The budget on file was printed before the year ended, and the minutes record amendments of that year's budget voted on or after that day, so the budget the year ended with is not on file. (29)
Money left unspent in a fund set aside for one purpose (bond and construction, grant, asset forfeiture and similar funds) is not reported as under budget, because there the appropriation is permission to spend restricted money as it comes in; this left out 12 comparisons.
What is missing or in doubt
Before a snapshot is published it is checked against itself and against the one before it. A failed check stops the publish. The checks below passed with these notes, and every record they name is marked where it appears.
-
Votes in doubt: a roll call that contradicts itself or the outcome, a vote reported again at a later meeting, or a vote of the Planning Commission. Each is marked where it appears. (40)
Examples
- motion 31140: Jennings seconded the motion and is listed as absent
- motion 30132: the same words are in the minutes of 2003-06-19, so this may be that vote reported again
- motion 30133: the same words are in the minutes of 2003-06-19, so this may be that vote reported again
- motion 30140: the same words are in the minutes of 2003-06-10, so this may be that vote reported again
- motion 30153: the same words are in the minutes of 2003-06-10, so this may be that vote reported again
- motion 29227: the minutes state 1 nays and 3 names are listed
- motion 29228: the minutes state 1 nays and 2 names are listed
- motion 29255: the minutes state 1 nays and 2 names are listed
-
Motions whose meeting cannot be told, because the pages of the minutes are filed out of order. They are in the data files and on no meeting's page. (2)
-
Names in roll calls that match no one on the roster. Their votes are in no member's record. (7)
Examples
- Blevins
- Charles Stevens
- Hendrick
- Neitch
- Regina Blevins
- Staley
- Weaver
-
58 document links could not be fetched (old or malformed addresses). Nothing from them is here.
-
7,331 of 24,361 pages (30%) are scanned images. Their text is not read, so motions and numbers on them are missing. In the minutes, where the Board's votes are recorded, 302 of 7,913 pages are scans. In agenda files and board packets, where the budget worksheets and attachments are, 7,029 of 16,448 pages are scans.
-
Budget amendments not compared with one percent, because the documents on file state no adopted total for their year or no total for the amendment. The page says so beside each. (5)
-
Votes on budget amendments that give no amendment number and no single total, so they are not listed. (1)
Examples
- 2022-02-24: https://www.smythcounty.gov/Document Centers/Agendas & Minutes/Board Of Supervisors Agendas & Minutes/2022/Minutes/min_bos_complete_2022.pdf#page=80
-
In the state Auditor's comparative report, a county's local revenue in Exhibit A differs from the total of its lines in Exhibit B. The comparison page says so where it shows one of these counties. (11)
Examples
- Russell: 37,928,149 (A F133), 35,183,693 (B AI133)
- Brunswick: 31,465,885 (A F66), 30,814,548 (B AI66)
- Buckingham: 26,459,128 (A F68), 26,081,563 (B AI68)
- Floyd: 29,058,350 (A F84), 27,504,538 (B AI84)
- Isle of Wight: 99,911,196 (A F99), 96,785,120 (B AI99)
- King & Queen: 17,813,210 (A F101), 16,611,402 (B AI101)
- Lee: 23,254,872 (A F105), 22,494,177 (B AI105)
- Northumberland: 30,685,857 (A F117), 30,084,980 (B AI117)
Beyond what the checks can see:
- The Board's minutes also print votes of the Planning Commission. They are labeled as such and count in no supervisor's record. One the software fails to recognize would be recorded as a Board vote; the ones that read that way are marked.
- Before 2012 the minutes usually record a vote by count, or as “unanimously carried,” without names. Of 4,416 Board motions from those years, 780 name at least one supervisor's vote. Supervisors' records for those years cover only those votes, so their counts run low.
- Old minutes sometimes print a vote again at a later meeting, and one of the county's yearly files includes some pages twice. A vote whose words and roll call both appear at an earlier meeting is marked, and may be counted twice.
- Only the Board of Supervisors is covered. The School Board, the towns and the Planning Commission are not here yet.
- The checks confirm the data agrees with itself. They cannot confirm that a number was read correctly from a PDF. That is why each number links to its page.
- Budget worksheets show what the county printed on the day of the packet. Audited results can differ.
Using this at a meeting
- Open the source link and read the page. Cite the county's document and page number, not this site.
- Ask a question the page raises. A finding tells you where to look; staff and supervisors can tell you why a number is what it is.
- If something here is wrong, the correction matters more than the point. Report it.